tradingdots

Stop Loss vs Stop Limit vs Trailing Stop: Which Order to Use

A stop-loss order guarantees an exit but not the price; a stop-limit guarantees the price but not the exit. A trailing stop follows a rising price to lock in gains.

Close-up of a candlestick price chart with moving average lines and buy and sell markers on a blue screen
In this guide
  1. Stop Loss vs Stop Limit vs Trailing Stop: The Basics
  2. How Stop-Loss and Stop-Limit Orders Work
  3. Stop Loss vs Stop Limit in a Gap Down: A Worked Example
  4. Stop Loss vs Trailing Stop Loss: How Trailing Stops Work
  5. Comparison Table: Stop-Market vs Stop-Limit vs Trailing Stop
  6. How to Set a Stop Loss Properly
  7. Stop Hunting: Myths and Realities
  8. Broker Differences and Crypto Exchange Equivalents
  9. Bottom Line: Which Order Should You Use?
  10. Sources

The difference between a stop loss vs stop limit order comes down to one trade-off: a stop-loss (stop-market) order guarantees you get out but not the price, while a stop-limit order guarantees the price but not that you get out. A trailing stop is a third option that moves your stop up automatically as a winning trade rises, so it can protect profits as well as limit losses.

Which one fits depends on what worries you more: a bad fill during a crash, or being stuck in a position that keeps falling.

Below you will find how each order works, a gap-down example showing slippage versus a non-fill, percentage versus dollar trailing stops, stop placement, stop hunting, broker differences and crypto equivalents. All examples are hypothetical and are not a recommendation to buy or sell anything.

Stop Loss vs Stop Limit vs Trailing Stop: The Basics

Before the details, here are plain definitions. Each order sits dormant until a stop price (the trigger level you choose) is reached.

  • Stop-loss order (stop-market order): when the stop price is reached, it becomes a market order, an instruction to sell (or buy) immediately at the best available price.
  • Stop-limit order: when the stop price is reached, it becomes a limit order, an instruction to sell only at your limit price or better.
  • Trailing stop order: a stop or stop-limit whose stop price is set as a percentage or dollar amount away from the market price and follows the price in your favor, but never moves back.

As the SEC puts it, the stop price is a trigger, not a guaranteed execution price. A sell stop sits below the current price to protect a long position (one you own); a buy stop sits above it to protect a short position (one you sold, betting on a fall).

How Stop-Loss and Stop-Limit Orders Work

Stop-loss (stop-market) order

Suppose you own a stock trading at $50 and place a sell stop at $46. Nothing happens while the price stays above $46. Once the stock trades at or below $46 (or, at some brokers, once the bid or ask reaches it), your order converts to a market order and sells at whatever price buyers are paying at that moment.

In a calm, liquid market, that fill is usually within a few cents of $46. In a fast market, it can be much lower. The difference between your stop price and your actual fill is called slippage. Slippage is the price you pay for certainty: a stop-market order almost always executes, because market orders take whatever liquidity is available.

Stop-market orders suit you when getting out matters more than the exact price, which covers most protective stops on liquid stocks, ETFs and major crypto pairs.

Stop-limit order

A stop-limit order has two prices: the stop price that activates it and the limit price that sets the worst price you will accept. With a stop at $46 and a limit at $45.50, your order activates when the stock hits $46 and then sells only at $45.50 or higher.

The benefit is control. You will never sell at $41 because of a sudden air pocket in the order book. The risk is that the price can drop straight through your limit, leaving the order unfilled while the stock keeps falling. The SEC notes that the stop and limit prices do not have to be the same; leaving a gap between them, such as stop $46 and limit $45.50, gives the order some room to fill in a fast move.

Stop-limits suit thinly traded stocks, wide-spread markets and entries (for example, buying a breakout without chasing a spike), where a bad fill would hurt more than a missed fill.

Stop Loss vs Stop Limit in a Gap Down: A Worked Example

The clearest way to see the trade-off is a gap, when a stock opens far from the previous close because of news released while the market was shut. No trades happen between the two prices, so no stop can fill in that range.

Example: Suppose you buy 100 shares at $50 and plan to risk $400, so you set your stop at $46. The stock closes at $47.50. After the close, the company cuts its guidance, and the next morning it opens at $40.

  • Stop-market order (stop $46): the open at $40 is below your stop, so the order triggers and becomes a market order. Say it fills at $39.90. Your loss is ($50 − $39.90) × 100 = $1,010, not the $400 you planned. Slippage was $46 − $39.90 = $6.10 a share, or $610.
  • Stop-limit order (stop $46, limit $45.50): the order triggers at the open, but it can only sell at $45.50 or better. With the stock at $40, it does not fill. You still own 100 shares worth $4,000, an open loss of $1,000.

What happens next decides which order “won.” If the stock slides to $36 by the end of the week, the stop-limit trader’s open loss grows to ($50 − $36) × 100 = $1,400 unless they sell manually, while the stop-market trader is out at a $1,010 loss. If the stock instead rebounds to $47, the stop-limit trader is down only $300 and the stop-market trader has locked in $1,010.

Neither order prevents the gap loss. A stop-market order caps further damage after the gap; a stop-limit order avoids selling at the low but leaves you exposed. That is why position size, not order type, is your real defense against gaps. Our guide to position sizing shows how to size so that even a gap through your stop is survivable.

Key warning: No standard stop order guarantees your exit price in stocks. Overnight gaps, trading halts and flash crashes can all produce fills far below your stop, or no fill at all with a stop-limit. Plan your risk assuming your stop could be skipped.

Stop Loss vs Trailing Stop Loss: How Trailing Stops Work

A fixed stop stays where you put it. A trailing stop moves up as the price makes new highs (for a long position) and stays put when the price falls. It locks in part of a gain without you having to edit the order every day.

You choose the trail as either a percentage or a dollar amount. A percentage trail scales with the price; a dollar trail keeps the same distance no matter how far the stock runs.

Example: percentage vs dollar trail. Suppose you buy a stock at $100 and compare two trailing sell stops.

  • 10% trailing stop: the stop starts at $90. If the stock climbs to $130, the stop rises to $130 × 0.90 = $117. If the stock then falls back, the stop stays at $117 and triggers there, locking in about $17 a share before slippage.
  • $8 trailing stop: the stop starts at $92. At a high of $130, it sits at $130 − $8 = $122, locking in about $22 a share. But at the start it was only 8% below the price, so ordinary wiggles were more likely to knock you out early.

The percentage trail widened from $10 to $13 as the price rose; the dollar trail stayed at $8, which became tighter in percentage terms (about 6.2% at $130).

A trailing stop can be a trailing stop-market or a trailing stop-limit, with the same trade-off as above. Most brokers update the trail based on the last trade price or quote during regular hours only, so check how yours handles pre-market and after-hours moves.

The main downside: trailing stops ignore market structure, so a 10% trail might sit just above support where a normal pullback will tag it. Many traders start with a fixed stop below structure and switch to a trailing stop, or trail manually below each new swing low, once the trade is in profit.

Comparison Table: Stop-Market vs Stop-Limit vs Trailing Stop

Feature Stop-loss (stop-market) Stop-limit Trailing stop
What triggers it Price reaches your stop price Price reaches your stop price Price falls a set % or $ from its highest point since you placed it
Becomes Market order Limit order at your limit price Market order (or limit, if trailing stop-limit)
Fill guaranteed? Almost always, in a functioning market No; may not fill if price jumps past the limit Same as the order it becomes
Price guaranteed? No; slippage possible Yes, limit price or better No for market version
Gap risk Fills at or near the gap price May leave you holding the position Same as stop-market or stop-limit
Best for Protective exits in liquid markets Illiquid assets, wide spreads, controlled entries Locking in gains on trending positions
Main drawback Bad fills in fast markets No exit when you need it most Can be hit by normal pullbacks

How to Set a Stop Loss Properly

A stop should sit where your trade idea is proven wrong, not where the loss “feels” acceptable. Then you size the position so that being wrong costs a fixed slice of your account, typically 0.5% to 2%. Our guide to risk management in trading covers that rule in detail.

Method 1: Place stops beyond market structure

For a long trade, look for the most recent meaningful swing low or a clear support level. If price falls below it, the pattern that justified the trade has broken. Put the stop a small buffer below that level rather than exactly on it, because many other traders’ stops cluster at the obvious price.

Method 2: Use the Average True Range (ATR)

The Average True Range (ATR), an indicator developed by J. Welles Wilder, measures how much an asset typically moves per bar, including gaps. A stop placed a multiple of ATR away, often 1.5× to 3×, sits outside normal noise for that particular stock.

Example: ATR stop and position size. Suppose you have a $20,000 account and risk 1% per trade ($200). You buy a stock at $80, and its 14-day ATR is $2.40. A 2× ATR stop is $2.40 × 2 = $4.80 below entry, at $75.20. Your position size is $200 ÷ $4.80 = 41.67, rounded down to 41 shares (about $3,280). If the stop fills exactly, the loss is 41 × $4.80 = $196.80.

Now check structure: if the last swing low is $76.50, the ATR stop at $75.20 sits $1.30 below it, which is a sensible buffer.

What should a stop loss be set at?

There is no universal percentage. A 5% stop is wide for a slow utility stock and tight for a small-cap biotech or a volatile altcoin. Combine the two methods above: find the level that invalidates the setup, make sure it is outside normal ATR noise, and then let the position size absorb the distance. If the logical stop is so far away that the position would be tiny, skip the trade. Pair the stop with a target so you know your risk-reward ratio before you enter.

Mental stops vs hard stops

A mental stop is an exit level you keep in your head instead of placing an order. It depends entirely on your discipline and on being at the screen. For most traders a resting order is better, because the common failure is not stop hunting but hesitating and moving the stop.

Stop Hunting: Myths and Realities

Stop hunting refers to price briefly pushing through an obvious level, triggering clustered stops, and then reversing. Traders often blame it for losses. The truth is more mundane.

What is real

  • Stops cluster. Many traders put stops just under round numbers, prior lows and popular moving averages. When price reaches those levels, triggered sell orders add pressure and can briefly extend the move, especially in thin markets such as the open, small caps or crypto weekends.
  • Some venues have conflicts. In lightly regulated crypto derivatives or offshore CFD platforms where the platform takes the other side of your trade, price feeds and liquidation engines deserve scrutiny.

What is mostly myth

  • “Someone is targeting my stop.” In US stocks, your stop order usually sits on your broker’s system, not on a public exchange order book, so other market participants do not see it. Large players care about pools of orders, not one retail position.
  • “Not using a stop is safer.” Removing stops trades a small, visible risk for a large, hidden one. The gap example above shows how far a stock can fall.

Practical fixes: place stops beyond the obvious level plus a buffer (for example, 0.5× ATR), avoid round numbers, and accept a smaller position so the wider stop costs the same dollar amount.

Broker Differences and Crypto Exchange Equivalents

How brokers handle stop orders

Stop orders are not identical across firms. The SEC tells investors to check their own broker’s rules, and the differences matter:

  • Trigger price: some brokers trigger stops on the last trade price; others use the bid or ask quote. A quote-based trigger can fire on a momentary wide spread without a trade at your level.
  • Who holds the order: the New York Stock Exchange stopped accepting stop orders in 2016, and many venues do not accept them, so most brokers hold your stop on their own systems and send a market or limit order when it triggers.
  • Trading hours: many brokers only trigger stops during the regular session (9:30 a.m. to 4:00 p.m. Eastern for US stocks). A stock can fall sharply after hours, and your stop will not act until the next open.
  • Duration: a day order expires at the close; a good-’til-canceled (GTC) order stays active until filled or canceled, but brokers often cap GTC orders at 60 to 180 days.
  • Guaranteed stops: some UK and EU spread-betting and CFD providers offer a guaranteed stop-loss order that fills at your exact price, even through a gap, for a premium charged if it triggers. Standard US stock brokers generally do not.

If you are still choosing where to trade, compare these order features when you open a brokerage account.

What crypto exchanges call these orders

Crypto exchanges use similar orders with different names. Because crypto trades 24/7, you avoid the classic overnight stock gap, but you face thin weekend liquidity and sudden “wicks” (brief price spikes) that can trigger stops.

  • Stop-market: often called “stop market” or “stop loss,” usually on advanced or pro interfaces.
  • Stop-limit: the most widely available stop on spot markets, including on simplified “advanced trade” screens. Some platforms offer only stop-limit for spot trading, which means a fast drop can skip your limit.
  • Trailing stop: offered by several large exchanges, usually as a percentage “callback rate” or trailing offset.
  • OCO (one-cancels-the-other): pairs a take-profit limit order with a stop order; when one fills, the other is canceled. Bracket orders work the same way.
  • Trigger price type on futures: derivatives platforms often let you trigger stops on the last price or the mark price (a smoothed fair-value price used for liquidations). Mark-price triggers are less prone to brief wicks on one exchange.

Order names and features change, so read your exchange’s help pages first. On leveraged positions, keep your stop well before your liquidation price, or the exchange may close the position first.

Bottom Line: Which Order Should You Use?

  • Liquid stocks and ETFs, protective exit: a stop-market order, with the position sized for gap risk.
  • Thinly traded stocks or wide spreads: a stop-limit with a meaningful gap between stop and limit, and a plan to exit manually if it does not fill.
  • A trade already well in profit: a trailing stop, set wider than normal daily swings, or move a fixed stop up below each new swing low.
  • Crypto spot: whatever your exchange offers, usually stop-limit, with the limit set far enough below the stop to fill during a wick.
  • Holding through earnings or major news: recognize that no stop protects you from the gap. Reduce size or close before the event.

In short, a stop-loss gets you out but may slip, a stop-limit protects your price but may leave you in, and a trailing stop follows a winner up and gives some of the gain back when it reverses. Size every position so that a stop, or a gap through it, costs an amount you can live with, and check your broker’s trigger rules, hours and order expiry first. For the price action behind your stop levels, see our technical analysis for beginners guide and the full trading hub.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Is a stop-limit or stop-loss order better?

Neither is better in every case. A stop-loss (stop-market) order is usually preferred for protective exits in liquid markets because it reliably gets you out. A stop-limit suits illiquid assets or entries where a bad fill would be worse than no fill.

What is the difference between a stop loss and a trailing stop loss?

A regular stop loss stays at a fixed price until you move it. A trailing stop loss follows the price up by a set percentage or dollar amount and stays put when the price falls, so it locks in part of a gain as a trade moves in your favor.

What should a stop loss be set at?

There is no single right percentage. Set it just beyond the level that would prove your trade idea wrong, such as below a recent swing low, and outside normal volatility, often 1.5 to 3 times the Average True Range. Then size the position so that hitting the stop costs about 1% of your account or less.

Can a stop-loss order fail to protect me?

Yes. A stop-loss triggers a market order, and if a stock gaps down overnight it will fill at the opening price, which may be far below your stop. A stop-limit can avoid that bad price but may not fill at all, leaving you in a falling position.

Do stop orders work in pre-market and after-hours trading?

Often not. Many US brokers only trigger stop orders during the regular session from 9:30 a.m. to 4:00 p.m. Eastern. Check your broker's rules, because a stock can move sharply outside those hours.

Is stop hunting real?

Partly. Stops cluster at obvious levels such as round numbers and prior lows, and brief moves through those levels can trigger many of them at once. But retail stop orders in US stocks usually sit on the broker's system, not a public order book, so individual stops are rarely targeted. Placing stops beyond obvious levels with a buffer helps.